Source item
Open original source ↗1/4
The viral "19% discount" in $SLV is a timing artifact, not a broken product.
The Official NAV is based on the London Fix (~7 AM ET). This means the official price missed the entire afternoon crash in the US futures market.🧵 https://t.co/1SaF2RhIB1
2/4
But the stress is still real.
The chart below recalculates SLV's "fair value" at 4 PM ET using spot prices to eliminate the timing lag.
When we do that, the "timing" 19% discount vanishes, revealing the real discount: -1.7%.
@dampedspring @EricBalchunas @SantiagoAuFund https://t.co/ptOcMNoJb2
3/4
While -1.7% sounds small vs 19%, it is historically massive.
This is the deepest liquidity dislocation in $SLV since Aug 9, 2011—the day after the US lost its AAA rating.
Discounts don't mean the ETF is broken. They signal the underlying market is under severe stress.
4/4
Today, it is silver-market stress (for now??). See the last few days of premium/discounts.
If silver "rights the ship" in the next few days, we live to fight another day.
If not, that "another day" might be now for the firms caught on the wrong side of this liquidity gap. https://t.co/YKjd5xABfE
4 segments
Segment 1 · characters 0–254 · Original segment ↗
Segment 2 · characters 256–557 · Original segment ↗
Segment 3 · characters 559–834 · Original segment ↗
Segment 4 · characters 836–1139 · Original segment ↗
Quoted context
These are the quoted author’s words.
Just to be clear, yes the discount is not what it appears bc the NAV is struck using London close so NY Noon ish. Prob more like 2% if we used 4pm NAV. That said, it's history is standardized w Noon close so it is to show just how crazy the afternoon was.
EricBalchunas ↗